• Login
  • My Account
  • Logout
  • Privacy
  • Cookie Policy

THATFILMGUY

Film Previews, News, Reviews and Lists

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Lists
  • Five Stars
  • News
You are here: Home / Film Reviews / Review: Sin City (2005)

Review: Sin City (2005)

November 21, 2011 by That Film Guy Leave a Comment

sin city[pullquote cite=”” type=”left, right”][amazon text=Amazon&template=carousel&chan=That Film Guy&asin=B004UGANG6][/pullquote] Frank Miller’s graphic novel receives perhaps the most faithful transfer to the silver screen of all of the comic book genre in this brutal and brilliant film by Robert Rodriguez. The two hour running time covers three separate tales set in Basin City, an American noir hell where lawlessness and brutality are part of the fabric of every day life.  With a heavy hitting cast which oozes quality from top to bottom, each story is in its own right is a triumph.

The stories revolve predominantly around Mickey Rourke’s ex-con seeking to avenge the murder of a hooker, Clive Owen helping the women of ‘Old Town’ remain free of pimps and the mob and Bruce Willis protecting a stripper from an evil psychopath.  Whilst the three main protagonists are men, the women of Sin City play as important a role and every major character is played by one of Hollywood’s A-List.  While this does not necessarily translate to a good film by default, here everyone is perfectly cast and each puts in a great turn.

With such a rich conversion from graphic novel to big screen, which could have forfeited substance for style, is not allowed to because of the strength of the stories.  With 90% of each frame in black and white, only the important areas are colourised, which allows for an extra layer of silent narrative to be told.  What it also allows is for some truly horrific scenes to be played out with white/yellow/red blood and gore as appropriate.  While this allows for the horror to unfold explicitly without always being stomach-churning due to the colouring, it is hard to think of another mainstream film that plunges the depraved depths of Sin City and lays it out so starkly.  In context however, and not everyone will agree, shot as it is, it does not feel like too much.

Feeling similar in narrative style to Pulp Fiction, there is less overlap between the stories and characters in Sin City but the overall atmosphere of the city is painted perfectly throughout.  Whilst Rodriguez is credited as director, Frank Miller gets a directing credit and Quentin Tarantino a special guest director credit but the stories knit together seamlessly and never feel disjointed.  Unlike Pulp Fiction, each new story is not prefaced by a subtitle, they just roll from one to the next with a fade.

With a cast that would make most studios weak at the knees and a conversion so perfect that Stan Lee must cry into his cornflakes every morning, Sin City is in the upper echelons of not only the comic book genre but films as a whole.

Andrew Last

Sin City: Ranked 8th in All Time Comic Book Films

« Previous
Review: Iron Man (2008)
Next »
Review: Oldboy (2003, South Korea)

About That Film Guy

A new group of film reviewers in the finest traditions of ThatFilmGuy.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Sponsor Website

JEDINET LINK

TOP LIST

Top 30 Christmas Films

Top 30 Christmas Films

  Love Actually (2011) It's a Wonderful Life (1946) Elf (2003) A Christmas Story … Read More

Top 30 Horror Films

Top 30 Horror Films

Our list of the Top 30 Horror Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Horror films are one of the … Read More

Top 30 Comedy Films

Top 30 Comedy Films

Our list of the Top 30 Comedy Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........One of the most popular and … Read More

Top 30 Animated Films

Top 30 Animated Films

Our list of the Top 30 Animated Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........The animated film genre … Read More

Top 30 Film Trilogies

Top 30 Film Trilogies

Our list of the Top 30 Movie Trilogies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Before the 1970s a film … Read More

Top 30 Classic Action Films

Top 30 Classic Action Films

Our list of the Top 30 Classic Action Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Catering for the … Read More

© 2022copyright Thatfilmguy.com and Trafford Innovations Limited