• Login
  • My Account
  • Logout
  • Privacy
  • Cookie Policy

THATFILMGUY

Film Previews, News, Reviews and Lists

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Lists
  • Five Stars
  • News
You are here: Home / Film Reviews / Another Earth (2011) review by That Film Guy

Another Earth (2011) review by That Film Guy

May 13, 2013 by That Film Guy Leave a Comment

Timing they say, is everything. Imagine director and co-writer Mike Cahill’s reaction when he found out that his bold, low-fi science fiction drama Another Earth was to be released mere weeks after Lars von Trier’s similarly themed Melancholia. You wait for a neat, original idea for ages and then the same one appears in two films in two weeks. Even more frustrating for Cahill and his lead star and other co-writer Brit Marling is that theirs is the lesser of the two films. That’s not to say that it’s bad though, far from it in fact.

Astrophysics student Rhoda (Marling) is driving home when she hears news that a planet almost identical to Earth has appeared in the sky. Not paying attention to the road, Rhoda crashes into a stationary car and the resulting tragedy leads to a prison term. Four years later, she is released back into the world at the same time that her planet are trying to make contact with ˜Earth 2.’ Desperate to travel to the alternate planet for a fresh start, she decides in the meantime to make a mends with the driver of the car she crashed in to (William Mapother), but finds herself becoming closer to him than she ever imagined.

For a film that starts with such a heavily science fiction premise, Another Earth at no point feels stereotypical. It’s a moving and engaging personal character drama which marks the emergence of two new talents in Cahill and Marling. It’s slow-paced and ponderous, but plays this to its advantage, making sure to intersperse the drama with interesting philosophical and scientific questions via TV or radio.

The salient points stay with you long after the film ends, although it must be said that it’s a little too long for a full-length feature. As with so many art house films there are moments of beauty to behold, but around the half-way mark you can’t help but beg for it to pick up the pace a bit. There’s only so much of watching characters looking at things that any audience should be subjected too. Still with a neatly ordered and well-acted character drama at its core, Another Earth has just enough to hold the attention of its audience, while raising interesting hypothetical questions to chew over after the credits have finished rolling.

 

 

Thomas Patrick 

 

« Previous
Dead Man Down (2013) review by That Film Brat
Next »
Review: Fast & Furious 6 (2013)

About That Film Guy

A new group of film reviewers in the finest traditions of ThatFilmGuy.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Sponsor Website

JEDINET LINK

TOP LIST

Top 30 Christmas Films

Top 30 Christmas Films

  Love Actually (2011) It's a Wonderful Life (1946) Elf (2003) A Christmas Story … Read More

Top 30 Horror Films

Top 30 Horror Films

Our list of the Top 30 Horror Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Horror films are one of the … Read More

Top 30 Comedy Films

Top 30 Comedy Films

Our list of the Top 30 Comedy Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........One of the most popular and … Read More

Top 30 Animated Films

Top 30 Animated Films

Our list of the Top 30 Animated Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........The animated film genre … Read More

Top 30 Film Trilogies

Top 30 Film Trilogies

Our list of the Top 30 Movie Trilogies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Before the 1970s a film … Read More

Top 30 Classic Action Films

Top 30 Classic Action Films

Our list of the Top 30 Classic Action Movies of all Time. Do you Agree?.........Catering for the … Read More

© 2019copyright Thatfilmguy.com and Trafford Innovations Limited